By Roger Langridge, Chris Samnee, Matthew Wilson, Rus Wooton
When reading superhero comics, it's often difficult to untangle objective analysis of the story's merits from appreciation of how that story manages to play off against the expectations of long-time fans. The genre is too entrenched, and its most prominent characters have been around too long, to see it through truly fresh eyes. Thor: the Mighty Avenger is no different in that respect. This retelling of the origin of a classic Marvel superhero is easily accessible to first time readers. But truthfully, much of the pleasure derived from the series comes from how the comic successfully reinvents and streamlines many of its well-worn elements so that they at least feel like they're new again.
What is immediately appealing is how writer Roger Langridge has removed the Marvel-style Sturm und Drang and replaced it with a low-key, leisurely paced approach to storytelling that leaves room for humor and more subtle character moments. It's far less melodramatic, but more human in scale. Jane Foster isn't just the love interest who prompts the hero into action, but the point-of-view character who bridges the gap between the mundane and the superhero worlds. Thor himself is an affable individual who can sometimes behave impetuously under pressure. The budding romance between the two anchors much of the story, making Thor's quest to return to Asgard all the more interesting.
The writing is ably complimented by the drawings of Chris Samnee, whose blocky and impressionistic linework isn't nearly as fussy as the more heavily rendered art found in many mainstream comics. Particularly noteworthy is how his figures are just stylized enough to appear fantastic, without resorting to outrageous bodybuilder type physiques dressed in skintight fetish-wear. Jane looks like an ordinary, if attractive brunette. Thor has the build of a heavyweight athlete. Hank Pym has a more slender frame. Namor the Sub Mariner has a lithe but muscular figure with a slightly alien appearance. This thoughtful approach to character design is nicely accompanied by the muted tones of colorist Matthew Wilson.
Even the fight scenes are considerably lighthearted, with comparatively little emphasis on collateral damage or bodily harm. Nor do they function as a metaphor for the inner demons the hero must confront and conquer. I particularly like how the confrontation between Hank and Thor was resolved by Hank using his brains instead of his brawn. Even the first meeting between Namor and Thor portrays the former as cool and calculating, and he ends up lecturing the latter on the value of humility. That's right, the guy who screamed "Imperious Rex" in past incarnations is telling Thor to bring it down a notch. Every fight serves as part of a learning process in order for Thor to eventually make his way back home of Asgard.
What this means is that Thor the Mighty Avenger doesn't fit in with the rest of Marvel's lineup: Not the mainline Marvel Universe, or the Ultimate Universe. And probably not with the upcoming Thor movie. This probably also means that the series won't last beyond the original creators' involvement with it. Frankly, that's not necessarily a bad thing.
10/22/2010
10/19/2010
Photos from the Hermit Kingdom
North Korea is in the news again, which is as good an excuse as any to dive into Guy Delisle's travelogue Pyongyang. There's a photo mockup of the book posted on his blog made by some of his fans. Good stuff, and that unfinished monstrosity the Ryugyong Hotel just looks atrocious.
10/15/2010
Louis Riel
I initially kept putting off reading Chester Brown's fictionalized biography on Louis Riel, intimidated by a combination of the book's massive size and the central importance of the character to Canada's national history. But I was also unsure what to make of the change in graphic style Brown adapted for the story. I thoroughly enjoyed reading his autobiographical explorations in The Playboy and I Never Liked You. So the approach used in Louis Riel didn't immediately appeal to me. But after getting over those concerns and finally diving into the work itself, I came to the conclusion that this is was one of the most engaging and beautiful comics that I've read in the last twenty years. That's quite a strong impression considering that its stark and minimal art, inspired by Harold Gray's Little Orphan Annie, stands in complete contrast to the increasingly lavish illustrative techniques and complex page layouts that have come to characterize some of the more notable examples of the medium. It's almost as if Brown set out to prove the viability of classic cartooning when applied to the modern graphic novel.
Brown's command of that language is remarkable. Despite my trepidation about the story's length, Louis Riel is a highly accessible narrative about a complex subject matter. In keeping with Harold Gray, Brown eschews dramatic close-ups, melodramatic displays of emotion, or changing panels arrangements. Even at its most intimate moments, Brown keeps the characters at middle distance. The characters are often portrayed at eye level or slightly above it, and usually in profile. Their faces are often masks that betray only subtle changes in emotions. The backgrounds are similarly sparse and the landscapes are very flat. This creates a certain theatrical staging for the characters' actions. There's also a quiet beauty and lonely majesty in many of the natural settings. Brown draws with clear and confident lines that require a minimum of fussy detailing and a strong sense of composition.
What such restraint does is allow the story to be told efficiently and with a minimum of distraction. The art conveys all the information necessary, allowing for an easy flow from panel to panel. The maintenance of an unchanging six panel grid also reinforces this. The caricature employed also effectively conveys each character's personalities without overselling it. Riel's spiky hair and unkempt appearance portray a certain directness that contrasts with the slyness portrayed by the bulbous nose and tweedy clothing of his nemesis Prime Minister John A. Macdonald. The uniformity of the panels isn't a hindrance when the story begins to focus on key events. Brown slows down the narrative with the use of a succession of barely changing images that adds to the gravitas of the proceedings. He also uses clever changes in the content of the panels to underline dramatic moments. The use of a blank white panel to show the moment of the Englishman Scott's death during his execution, or the use of black panels during Macdonald's decision to drive the Métis into rebellion, and during the jury's deliberation at Riel's trial. Deceptively simple, none of this minimalism is easy to accomplish.
For those unaware of what this book is all about, Louis Riel was a political leader of the Métis, a French translation for the Spanish "mestizo" - used in colonial times to describe people of mixed race. In the context of the story, the Métis were descendants of various European colonial (predominantly French speaking) and Native American populations. Riel would lead two armed rebellions against a primarily Anglophone Canadian government bent on limiting Métis representation within mainstream society. Eventually captured, tried, and executed, Riel was originally painted as a lunatic terrorist bent on the destruction of Canada. Today Riel's image has been largely rehabilitated as that of a freedom fighter who stood for the human rights of the Métis against the racist bigotry of the time. He's now recognized as a founder of the province of Manitoba.
This book isn't a comprehensive biography of Riel's life. Rather it focuses mainly on his political career. Brown's restraint also applies to his judgement on Riel's political legacy. Neither an unadulterated saint or a villain, Riel comes across as an astute and contradictory figure. A person who fought for the down-to-earth concerns of his people while being something of a religious fanatic. Was Riel a traitor or a patriot? Was he insane or simply intensely devoted? Was he a messianic figure, or a crackpot? Was he the rugged individualist standing up to the power of overbearing corporate interests and culpable state leaders, or a delusional thinker. Brown avoids giving pat answers to these questions. Sometimes this self-discipline has its downsides. For all his brilliance, it's never clear why Riel inspired such loyalty within the Métis community, especially when his convictions began to negatively impact the Métis cause. And Brown is unusually circumspect about exploring in greater depth the nature of Riel's clinically diagnosed insanity vs. his spiritual visions. Thus the book leaves his individual motivations unclear.
It should also be noted that as a work of historical fiction, Brown inevitably takes certain liberties with events in order to provide a clearer reading experience. But he is quite upfront about this and provides copious notes about how his interpretation differs from the actual facts of the events which are worth examining in themselves.
Louis Riel first appeared in serialized form before being collected into trade paperback. While the publisher still sells at least some the original pamphlets, I really can't imagine how the story benefits from having to consume it in serial installments. As far as I'm concerned, Louis Brown works better as a massive, singular tome.
Bonus: Kate Beaton has her own funny take on Riel.
Brown's command of that language is remarkable. Despite my trepidation about the story's length, Louis Riel is a highly accessible narrative about a complex subject matter. In keeping with Harold Gray, Brown eschews dramatic close-ups, melodramatic displays of emotion, or changing panels arrangements. Even at its most intimate moments, Brown keeps the characters at middle distance. The characters are often portrayed at eye level or slightly above it, and usually in profile. Their faces are often masks that betray only subtle changes in emotions. The backgrounds are similarly sparse and the landscapes are very flat. This creates a certain theatrical staging for the characters' actions. There's also a quiet beauty and lonely majesty in many of the natural settings. Brown draws with clear and confident lines that require a minimum of fussy detailing and a strong sense of composition.
What such restraint does is allow the story to be told efficiently and with a minimum of distraction. The art conveys all the information necessary, allowing for an easy flow from panel to panel. The maintenance of an unchanging six panel grid also reinforces this. The caricature employed also effectively conveys each character's personalities without overselling it. Riel's spiky hair and unkempt appearance portray a certain directness that contrasts with the slyness portrayed by the bulbous nose and tweedy clothing of his nemesis Prime Minister John A. Macdonald. The uniformity of the panels isn't a hindrance when the story begins to focus on key events. Brown slows down the narrative with the use of a succession of barely changing images that adds to the gravitas of the proceedings. He also uses clever changes in the content of the panels to underline dramatic moments. The use of a blank white panel to show the moment of the Englishman Scott's death during his execution, or the use of black panels during Macdonald's decision to drive the Métis into rebellion, and during the jury's deliberation at Riel's trial. Deceptively simple, none of this minimalism is easy to accomplish.
For those unaware of what this book is all about, Louis Riel was a political leader of the Métis, a French translation for the Spanish "mestizo" - used in colonial times to describe people of mixed race. In the context of the story, the Métis were descendants of various European colonial (predominantly French speaking) and Native American populations. Riel would lead two armed rebellions against a primarily Anglophone Canadian government bent on limiting Métis representation within mainstream society. Eventually captured, tried, and executed, Riel was originally painted as a lunatic terrorist bent on the destruction of Canada. Today Riel's image has been largely rehabilitated as that of a freedom fighter who stood for the human rights of the Métis against the racist bigotry of the time. He's now recognized as a founder of the province of Manitoba.
This book isn't a comprehensive biography of Riel's life. Rather it focuses mainly on his political career. Brown's restraint also applies to his judgement on Riel's political legacy. Neither an unadulterated saint or a villain, Riel comes across as an astute and contradictory figure. A person who fought for the down-to-earth concerns of his people while being something of a religious fanatic. Was Riel a traitor or a patriot? Was he insane or simply intensely devoted? Was he a messianic figure, or a crackpot? Was he the rugged individualist standing up to the power of overbearing corporate interests and culpable state leaders, or a delusional thinker. Brown avoids giving pat answers to these questions. Sometimes this self-discipline has its downsides. For all his brilliance, it's never clear why Riel inspired such loyalty within the Métis community, especially when his convictions began to negatively impact the Métis cause. And Brown is unusually circumspect about exploring in greater depth the nature of Riel's clinically diagnosed insanity vs. his spiritual visions. Thus the book leaves his individual motivations unclear.
It should also be noted that as a work of historical fiction, Brown inevitably takes certain liberties with events in order to provide a clearer reading experience. But he is quite upfront about this and provides copious notes about how his interpretation differs from the actual facts of the events which are worth examining in themselves.
Louis Riel first appeared in serialized form before being collected into trade paperback. While the publisher still sells at least some the original pamphlets, I really can't imagine how the story benefits from having to consume it in serial installments. As far as I'm concerned, Louis Brown works better as a massive, singular tome.
Bonus: Kate Beaton has her own funny take on Riel.
10/12/2010
10/07/2010
10/06/2010
The Mighty Magnor
By Sergio Aragonés, Mark Evanier, Tom Luth, Stan Sakai
In 1993 the then wildly popular Image Comics ended their partnership with Malibu Comics, leaving the latter company with a huge infusion of cash reserves which they used in part to fund a new line of comic books. But Malibu's success was rather short-lived, and the publisher was purchased in 1994 by their bigger rival Marvel Comics. One of those discontinued titles was from the team led by Sergio Aragonés and Mark Evanier. Bringing their Mad Magazine brand of satire to the superhero genre, they created six issues of The Mighty Magnor. In the letters section a buoyant Mark expressed hoped that the series would go on to be have a long and successful run. Yeah, those were the days. Mark does mention on his website that there was once a Spanish language trade paperback. Other than that, I'm unaware of Magnor being reprinted elsewhere.
Like Groo the Wanderer, Magnor is about a thick-headed protagonist who wreaks mass destruction every time he attempts to perform heroic acts. In reality he's an amnesiac super-powered alien soldier who crash lands on Earth. He's then discovered wandering the streets of New York by two wannabe comics professionals, C.J. Delaney and Gil Gillman. They take him back to their studio and hire him to model for their new superhero series called "The Mighty Magnor". While there, "Magnor" reads C.J. and Gil's entire comic book collection, and begins to believe that he's an actual superhero. Unfortunately, his crime-fighting goes unappreciated by the police mainly because his actions tend to cause significant collateral damage. But things only get worse when the evil ruler of Magnor's home planet attempts to retrieve him.
Magnor is a hilarious snapshot of the excesses within the comic book industry at the time. The protagonist himself is a walking cliche of the increasingly violent superheroes that dominated the market. Magnor has no personality of his own, but speaks entirely in dialogue lifted from television and comic books. That probably makes him just a tad less engaging than Groo. Other issues that weighed heavily on Sergio and Mark's minds are the burgeoning awareness of creator rights and the speculator craze driving demand for comic books. The only editor in the entire series is a money-grubbing, over the top figure who barely pays his employees while profiting from their work. He does get his comeuppance in the end. Meanwhile, scorn is heaped on the practice of bagging comic books without reading them. This must have been a real pet peeve at the time, given the way the story keeps coming back to the issue.
Anyway, here are my favorite pages in the series:
I really enjoy this two page spread, especially the love given to Jack Kirby. I keep imagining Rob Liefeld and Frank Miller being among the people kissing his ass. Actually, it was the news of Comic Con's decision to stay in San Diego for at least the next five years that brought back memories of this image, and prompted me to take another look at Magnor.
Re-reading Magnor seventeen years after its initial release imbues it with a oddly nostalgic vibe. Sure, the comic book industry would implode soon after. And yes, the superhero remains the one true genre within the Direct Market. But it would never regain the glamour it had during this period, nor would its comics be attached to such over-hyped superstars. And as much as Sergio and Mark poke fun of superheroes, a real affection for the genre does come through. It's also rather quaint how much more centered the comic book industry was around the DM back then. So is its comparatively nascent working relationship with mainstream media. While the series skewers Hollywood's increasing involvement with comic books, it never gets past portraying it as a brief and dangerous flirtation. And as a comic written before the world wide web exploded into the public's consciousness, the story's context almost feels like looking into the last days of some medieval era before the introduction of movable type. But creator rights and copyright ownership is an important issue tackled in Magnor that continues to be unresolved, and has only gotten a whole lot more complicated since then.
Then there's this conversation between two nameless pedestrians spotting Magnor on the street:
In 1993 the then wildly popular Image Comics ended their partnership with Malibu Comics, leaving the latter company with a huge infusion of cash reserves which they used in part to fund a new line of comic books. But Malibu's success was rather short-lived, and the publisher was purchased in 1994 by their bigger rival Marvel Comics. One of those discontinued titles was from the team led by Sergio Aragonés and Mark Evanier. Bringing their Mad Magazine brand of satire to the superhero genre, they created six issues of The Mighty Magnor. In the letters section a buoyant Mark expressed hoped that the series would go on to be have a long and successful run. Yeah, those were the days. Mark does mention on his website that there was once a Spanish language trade paperback. Other than that, I'm unaware of Magnor being reprinted elsewhere.
Like Groo the Wanderer, Magnor is about a thick-headed protagonist who wreaks mass destruction every time he attempts to perform heroic acts. In reality he's an amnesiac super-powered alien soldier who crash lands on Earth. He's then discovered wandering the streets of New York by two wannabe comics professionals, C.J. Delaney and Gil Gillman. They take him back to their studio and hire him to model for their new superhero series called "The Mighty Magnor". While there, "Magnor" reads C.J. and Gil's entire comic book collection, and begins to believe that he's an actual superhero. Unfortunately, his crime-fighting goes unappreciated by the police mainly because his actions tend to cause significant collateral damage. But things only get worse when the evil ruler of Magnor's home planet attempts to retrieve him.
Magnor is a hilarious snapshot of the excesses within the comic book industry at the time. The protagonist himself is a walking cliche of the increasingly violent superheroes that dominated the market. Magnor has no personality of his own, but speaks entirely in dialogue lifted from television and comic books. That probably makes him just a tad less engaging than Groo. Other issues that weighed heavily on Sergio and Mark's minds are the burgeoning awareness of creator rights and the speculator craze driving demand for comic books. The only editor in the entire series is a money-grubbing, over the top figure who barely pays his employees while profiting from their work. He does get his comeuppance in the end. Meanwhile, scorn is heaped on the practice of bagging comic books without reading them. This must have been a real pet peeve at the time, given the way the story keeps coming back to the issue.
Anyway, here are my favorite pages in the series:
I really enjoy this two page spread, especially the love given to Jack Kirby. I keep imagining Rob Liefeld and Frank Miller being among the people kissing his ass. Actually, it was the news of Comic Con's decision to stay in San Diego for at least the next five years that brought back memories of this image, and prompted me to take another look at Magnor.
Re-reading Magnor seventeen years after its initial release imbues it with a oddly nostalgic vibe. Sure, the comic book industry would implode soon after. And yes, the superhero remains the one true genre within the Direct Market. But it would never regain the glamour it had during this period, nor would its comics be attached to such over-hyped superstars. And as much as Sergio and Mark poke fun of superheroes, a real affection for the genre does come through. It's also rather quaint how much more centered the comic book industry was around the DM back then. So is its comparatively nascent working relationship with mainstream media. While the series skewers Hollywood's increasing involvement with comic books, it never gets past portraying it as a brief and dangerous flirtation. And as a comic written before the world wide web exploded into the public's consciousness, the story's context almost feels like looking into the last days of some medieval era before the introduction of movable type. But creator rights and copyright ownership is an important issue tackled in Magnor that continues to be unresolved, and has only gotten a whole lot more complicated since then.
Then there's this conversation between two nameless pedestrians spotting Magnor on the street:
- It's the most powerful man in the comic book world!- That's Todd MacFarlane?Oh, how the might have fallen.
10/02/2010
More NonSense: No More Mutants
![]() |
| Marvel Graphic Novel #5: God Loves, Man Kills, 1982, by Chris Claremont, Brent Eric Anderson, et. al. |
Comics’ default position on diversity seems to be one of avoidance – a position that’s perfectly summed up by the Scarlet Witch’s memorable phrase, ‘No more mutants’. Those three words might also suggest the best way forward; let’s stop talking in metaphors and put the actual minorities in comics, to tell their own stories.Andrew Wheeler has written an interesting series of columns in which he tackles how mainstream comics (i.e. Marvel and DC) have attempted to deal with the issues of racial prejudice, sexual inequality, and dubious minority representations. It's a informative survey of the seemingly arbitrary and incoherent editorial decisions that publishers make in order to preserve continuity. These choices inevitably induce a fair degree of defensiveness amongst fans. But that's a whole other topic for discussion. For now, "No more mutants" sentiment is a good place to start.
- Andrew Wheeler
I'm not closely following the events within the X-titles that gave rise to that phrase, so I can't really say how this latest mutant massacre differs from other past massacres. But Andrew does briefly touch on one thing about the X-Men that's bugged me for a long time now - While the mutants are clearly an oppressed minority within the context of the Marvel Universe, they are an incomplete metaphor for this thing in the real world called "race". The X-Men comics traditionally viewed race from a mainly negative perspective, which was one of discrimination and resentment. Mutants were either hunted-down and rounded-up, recalling genocidal campaigns of the past. Or they were lynched, echoing similar practices from American history.
![]() |
| Uncanny X-Men #196, 1985, by Chris Claremont, John Romita, Jr. et. al. |
What was missing in these portrayals was a preestablished culture. If people are going to insist that mutants are a metaphor for real-world racial politics, then the lack of an ancient tradition is a pretty big omission. The mutants began as a blank slate. As minorities go, they didn't have their own archaic customs, norms, myths, art or science. They didn't have their own alternate history that was being suppressed by a more powerful group. As a social classification, they're still brand new. They started out in the comic pages being vaguely defined by a popular misinterpretation of science (the X-gene and the effects of radiation), and were unable to counteract it with any kind of long-established, internally generated, traditional identity. The oft-repeated claim that mutants are the next step in human evolution puts them light years apart from the ground-level concerns of real ethnic groups who face discrimination because they are viewed as inferior and backward. And if I recall correctly, the original members of the X-Men were white teenagers born and raised within mainstream American culture. They were simply denied by their own society's widespread prejudice from openly integrating into it. So it's no surprise that they were a miserable lot (That and living in a never-ending soap opera). That's not the same as people being feared, hated, or treated with casual condescension because they openly identify with an altogether alien (e.g. non-European) community or ancestry. If the X-Men were ever a suitable analog for any particular group of people, it would be for the series' geeky fanbase who were searching for the perfect comic book vehicle for their own adolescent frustrations.
![]() |
| New X-Men #135, 2003, by Grant Morrison, Frank Quitely, et. al. |
Now, it's not unrealistic to expect any minority group being ostracized for whatever reasons (age, gender, sexual orientation, profession, hobbies, skills, unique abilities etc.) to form their own counter-culture at some point. Marvel's mutant population should be no different in this regard. There should be mutant artists, musicians, writers, designers and other creative types. There should be respected intellectual figures along with vapid celebrities. If there's already a school for mutants, where are the museums, galleries, theatres, clubs, restaurants, and other institutions which are, at the very least, sensitive to mutant perspectives? And if there's a mutant counter-culture, wouldn't this inevitably spill over to the rest of the Marvel universe? A couple of writers have tried to explore this area. The tentative beginnings within the series could arguably be traced back to arch-villain Magneto's separatist ideas. Mike Allred put mutants under the media spotlight when he took over X-Force. But the process was only accelerated to its logical conclusion when rebellious teenagers started worshipping their own mutant idols during Grant Morrison's run on New X-Men. I guess that's all being undone now in the name of bringing the X-Men back to their secretive roots. As Andrew quotes editor-in-chief Joe Quesada:
"...we ended up with a mutant island where there were over six million of them, and every time you’d turn a page, you’d see a mutant on every corner. We even had ‘Mutant Town’. So, one of the things that we wanted to do was put the genie back in the bottle.”Taken on it's own terms, what's being voiced unfortunately sounds too much like: God forbid if minorities of any kind could be spotted openly walking down the street of every major city, living wherever they choose, or be allowed to congregate at their own preferred hangouts. Especially if it messes with the superhero universe's precious status quo.
![]() |
| New X-Men #135, 2003, by Grant Morrison, Frank Quitely, et. al. |
I'm not necessarily implying that this editorial decision is being consciously motivated by racism or sexism, or any other form of intolerance. But it does highlight how working with decades-old legacy characters, while being beholden to accepted modes of expression, can sometimes make it harder for creators and readers who want to explore new and possibly fertile ground. Creative change is being proscribed by genre convention, fastidious fandom, or protective intellectual property owners.
Or perhaps Marvel's merry band of misfits are just no longer the optimal vehicle to drive a relevant discussion on race and diversity, if they were ever one at all.
9/30/2010
9/27/2010
9/26/2010
Drawing Down The Moon
By Charles Vess, Susanna Clarke
As someone who enjoys the work of popular fantasy illustrator Charles Vess, I haven't followed his development as an artist all that closely. So a lot of the images compiled within the pages of this 200 page retrospective Drawing Down the Moon: The Art of Charles Vess were a pleasant surprise. If I had to sum up his oeuvre as presented in this book, it would be that Vess has been extremely succesful in pursuing projects that were suitable to his individual talents. For example, he's returned to William Shakespeare's ageless comedy A Midsummer Night's Dream several times throughout his career. That choice is emblematic of him - Vess seems particularly drawn to stories that deal with the intersection between the realms of the mundane and the magical.
One thing that I can relate to some degree are his various artistic influences. Vess cites comics legends such as Jack Kirby, George Herriman, Russ Manning, and Hal Foster. But he was also strongly informed by the work of classic fantasy illustrators from the late 19th and early 20th century such as Maxfield Parrish, Arthur Rackham, Richard Dadd, Alphonse Mucha, and Howard Pyle. Some of his early attempts at comic book storytelling are reproduced, and show that Vess had already learned to blend his comic and illustration influences. Vess exhibited many of the characteristics of his illustration heroes: The lithe figures, pastoral settings, the finely textured pen and ink cross hatching, and the harmonious color palette and subdued tones of his subtractive style of painting. Vess had all the necessary tools to become an accomplished artist. Those youthful efforts contained just the smallest hints of the command for multi-layered tableaux and the mastery of fanciful decorative elements found in his later, more mature work.
One big misstep, from the way he tells it, was enrolling at the department of painting and printmaking of Virginia Commonwealth University, where he graduated with a BFA. Whatever valuable technical skills he acquired came at the expense of disapproval from his peers. At the time the faculty was strongly influenced by the abstract expressionist movement - the antithesis to the narrative art dear to Vess. "I had to struggle for many years to regain that lost, individual sense of whimsical fantasy that those school years tried to squelch." I guess the pop art movement had not yet penetrated the walls of VCU's academia.
Another odd choice which is only briefly touched on were his attempts to work for Heavy Metal magazine. The publication's emphasis on sci-fi, combined with a preference for a brighter, more garish palette, buff figures, and a blood-and-guts approach more in line with Frank Frazetta than with Aubrey Beardsley (just to name two of Vess' early heroes) seemed like a poor fit. Unsurprisingly, one of the magazine's editors would describe his art as "too nice" for their purposes.
However, working in the comic book industry allowed Vess to eventually make his way back to the faerie idiom and narrative illustration, especially when he began collaborating with fan-favorite writer Neil Gaiman - a professional relationship that continues up to the present. His paintings for Gaiman's novel Stardust remains his most ambitious, and one of his most successful, bodies of work to date. Along with wider recognition came greater freedom to choose who to collaborate with and which stories were available to illustrate: whether it was the victorian-era J.M. Barrie's Peter Pan, modern emulators like Charles de Lint and Susanna Clarke, the darker horror-fantasies of George R.R. Martin, pro bono work for local community organizations, or his own self-publishing efforts through Green Man Press. While some of these projects are bound to come across better than others, depending on the reader's own tastes, there's a remarkable stylistic consistency to his art in this later period of his career that speaks to how carefully he's built his reputation as one the industry's foremost fantasy illustrators.
While I have my own quibbles with the book's design (I don't particularly care for the cover's color scheme and would have preferred the text to blend into the cover image), there's not much to complain about the content of the book. Susanna Clarke provides a fairly apt introduction. Apart from the reproductions of the finished artwork, there are samples of some of the underlying line art sprinkled throughout the book. Vess indulges the art geeks by concluding with an informative section on how he created the book's cover art. Overall, Drawing Down the Moon is as satisfying a retrospective as any found in today's market.
As someone who enjoys the work of popular fantasy illustrator Charles Vess, I haven't followed his development as an artist all that closely. So a lot of the images compiled within the pages of this 200 page retrospective Drawing Down the Moon: The Art of Charles Vess were a pleasant surprise. If I had to sum up his oeuvre as presented in this book, it would be that Vess has been extremely succesful in pursuing projects that were suitable to his individual talents. For example, he's returned to William Shakespeare's ageless comedy A Midsummer Night's Dream several times throughout his career. That choice is emblematic of him - Vess seems particularly drawn to stories that deal with the intersection between the realms of the mundane and the magical.
One thing that I can relate to some degree are his various artistic influences. Vess cites comics legends such as Jack Kirby, George Herriman, Russ Manning, and Hal Foster. But he was also strongly informed by the work of classic fantasy illustrators from the late 19th and early 20th century such as Maxfield Parrish, Arthur Rackham, Richard Dadd, Alphonse Mucha, and Howard Pyle. Some of his early attempts at comic book storytelling are reproduced, and show that Vess had already learned to blend his comic and illustration influences. Vess exhibited many of the characteristics of his illustration heroes: The lithe figures, pastoral settings, the finely textured pen and ink cross hatching, and the harmonious color palette and subdued tones of his subtractive style of painting. Vess had all the necessary tools to become an accomplished artist. Those youthful efforts contained just the smallest hints of the command for multi-layered tableaux and the mastery of fanciful decorative elements found in his later, more mature work.
One big misstep, from the way he tells it, was enrolling at the department of painting and printmaking of Virginia Commonwealth University, where he graduated with a BFA. Whatever valuable technical skills he acquired came at the expense of disapproval from his peers. At the time the faculty was strongly influenced by the abstract expressionist movement - the antithesis to the narrative art dear to Vess. "I had to struggle for many years to regain that lost, individual sense of whimsical fantasy that those school years tried to squelch." I guess the pop art movement had not yet penetrated the walls of VCU's academia.
![]() |
| The Fairy Market |
![]() |
| They Were Like Knights and Great Ladies out of Some Medieval Story Book |
![]() |
| The Merry Dancer's Emporium |
![]() |
| A Dream of Apples |
9/25/2010
More NonSense: Personal Expression on the Internet
The challenge for their managers is a subtle one: How to infuse their coverage with the distinctive human voices of journalistic observers who no longer wish to suppress their personal perspectives, while also insuring that the big megaphones they own do not turn into amplifiers of treacherous rumors, personal vendettas, or partisan lies.
- Scott Rosenberg on the new journalism fostered by the Internet
PR isn't journalism, but it's getting more social, and smarter PR people realize that they, too, have a stake in showing some integrity. Think tanks and NGOs increasingly are filling a journalistic role.
- Dan Gillmor responds
...we should all be clear that it's almost certain that Norris made the imam's list not for this expression of her ideas but because folks turned her expression into a Facebook campaign that garnered a lot of attention despite Norris wishing to be disassociated from it. Nice job, you dumbasses.
- Tom Spurgeon on Molly Norris and the campaign she inspired
Update: Tom has more to say about Norris and the Danish cartoon controversy:
That this remains an issue in the news speaks to the broad, bland immaturity of the modern political world and the obvious, sad fact that nothing was learned. In fact, learning was resisted. Almost no one's conduct during that time was challenged or questioned, no matter how self-serving the subsequent spin.
- Scott Rosenberg on the new journalism fostered by the Internet
PR isn't journalism, but it's getting more social, and smarter PR people realize that they, too, have a stake in showing some integrity. Think tanks and NGOs increasingly are filling a journalistic role.
- Dan Gillmor responds
![]() |
| The original Everybody Draw Mohammed Day poster by Molly Norris |
- Tom Spurgeon on Molly Norris and the campaign she inspired
Update: Tom has more to say about Norris and the Danish cartoon controversy:
That this remains an issue in the news speaks to the broad, bland immaturity of the modern political world and the obvious, sad fact that nothing was learned. In fact, learning was resisted. Almost no one's conduct during that time was challenged or questioned, no matter how self-serving the subsequent spin.
9/23/2010
9/21/2010
Reviving our Industry
![]() |
| Image from Wikipilipinas |
1) Creating financial incentives to help efforts of komiks creators might sound like a good idea in general, but some of the language of the bills strikes me as a tad old-fashioned. From the later Senate bill:
Komiks has been the champion of the masses: political, sociological, and financial issues; the mirror of the country's times: dreams and disillusions, passions, and fashions; cultural anchor: a gentle reminder of our heritage and values; and a teacher as it contributes to the propagation of the Pilipino language in a country of more than 70 languages, thereby strengthening the Filipino race and the national language.
Sadly, with the advent of computer games, compact discs, digital video discs, and the internet, the local komiks industry suffered. Moreover, the best illustrators in the local komiks industry have been lured by the high pay they received in the United States. Thus, the joy of reading komiks has been set aside and, as a consequence, results in the twin evils of diminishing readership and illiteracy.
There's a bit of nostalgia for those good old days when komiks was a major publishing venture, mixed with economic protectionism, and a bit of nationalist boosterism for good measure. But nothing in the bill shows any forward thinking about how to respond to comics increased internet presence, its growth as a digital medium, the massive popularity of manga, or the protection of free speech and artistic expression. When looked in the context of the anti-child pornography bill passed last year, there's not a lot in the bill to prevent at least some komiks from being used as a form of government propaganda.
2) The mandating that 10% of printed educational material be komiks dredges up personal memories of attending elementary school religion classes: Komiks were a regular part, actually a big part, of moral and spiritual instruction. I don't know if that was a quirk of the particular school I attended, and in truth I remember next to nothing about the content of the stories. It's been awhile since I've been to a Filipino school. But I think they made more of an impression (both bad and good) than the regular textbooks. This was a private school, and most private schools are still religious in their affiliation.
3) Komiks was no more recognized as a legitimate artform during its heyday by the general public than when Jack Kirby was toiling away at Marvel Comics at the height of his professional career. Komiks continues to be a marginal presence, often obscured by the current influx of American and Japanese imports. And those foreign products in themselves aren't usually treated as legitimate artistic works. It's understandable if people act a little defensively about komiks vis-a-vis other comics traditions. But if komiks wants to be recognized as a worthy artistic medium, there needs to be some maturation within local fandom itself in their overall perception of the comics medium.
4) Given the heavy-handed, values-laden rhetoric that characterizes Filipino politics, I'm not sure I want the government too involved with my beloved medium. While I like the idea of tax breaks and other financial incentives, I'm concerned about the censorship that inevitably follows when local politicians become interested in mass media (Such as in the Filipino film industry, which the bill mentions as a sterling example of effective government support. Komiks has also had its own version of the Comics Code Authority). It's a dilemma that Filipino creators are going to be concerned about.
9/17/2010
9/12/2010
The Arrival
To begin on a personal note, I'm surprised that I didn't read The Arrival when it first came out, considering how celebrated a figure Shaun Tan is in Australia. I do remember making a perfunctory search for his works at a few Brisbane comic book stores before losing interest. Shows how much I know. In retrospect, Tan's book now seems almost a timely response to the wave of xenophobia then sweeping the country. This is far from a polemical work. Rather, Tan chooses to address the history of modern diasporas in broadly universal terms.Shaun Tan came to the comics medium from the completely different tradition of children's book illustration. So he was a virtual unknown to most comic book fans despite significant mainstream recognition, especially in his home country of Australia. It also may not have helped with certain segments of comics fandom that the children's book illustrator's approach to narrative art emphasizes divergent aesthetic qualities from most comic book art. Tan's use of graphite to draw photorealistic images, reminiscent of Chris Van Allsburg, is unusual for comics. But such lavish rendering is not atypical in children's picture books.
One consequence of Tan's illustrative style is that it prevents him from utilizing many of the narrative conventions and iconography found in comics. But I suspect that Tan is either too unlearned or uninterested in those techniques to have taken full advantage of them anyway. Instead, Tan employs the virtuosity of his art to draw sepia-toned images that are strongly suggestive of old passports and faded photos of immigrants coming to the New World. This creates an impression that one is looking into someone's past. But the art also has a sensuous quality, not just as a found object, but also within the images themselves. At the story's beginning various household objects are seen in isolation through a series of small panels before the view pulls back to reveal a family of three packing them into a suitcase. The quiet poignancy of the domestic scene is cut short when the trio steps outside into city streets full of crumbling tenement buildings being menaced by enormous, dragon-like coils. These objects have a powerful literal presence within the panels. But both the coils and buildings simultaneously work as metaphors for the dire conditions that are forcing the family to flee to a better place. The surreal imagery works to a great extent because of Tan's detailed artwork.
The father's exodus grows increasingly fantastical. The first part of this book heavily references contemporary photos of immigrants traveling to and being processed at Ellis Island: from the cramped conditions of ships steerage; the New York style skyline; and the bureaucratic nightmare immigrants experienced when being processed by the government. But the promised land they finally enter looks like a combination of a 20th century metropolis, an abstract expressionist landscape, and a child's play-land, with a hint of Jim Woodring's "The Unifactor". Elevators and mailboxes are carried by balloons, birds look like origami fold-outs, people commute on flying boats, and family pets all look like eccentric cartoon animals. This is a wondrous and somewhat frightening utopia where people from other parts of the world have fled from tyranny, slavery, and war - truly a "New World".
While Tan's page layouts and panel compositions are conventional, he has an intuitive grasp of comics-style pacing. Small square panels portraying little details and nondescript actions carry the reader along until the view expands with the use of page spreads to include a larger tableaux. The uniform simplicity of his panel arrangements and the photorealism of his art are sometimes reminiscent of cinematic storyboards and the sequences of Eadweard Muybridge. I particularly liked how the characters communicate through subtle movements and small gestures instead of more typical over-the-top posturing. His narrative is assured, controlled, and easily accessible to the mainstream reader.
I mentioned at the beginning that The Arrival almost seems like a response to the widespread anti-immigrant sentiment of the time. However, Tan neither directly addresses the casual or institutionalized racism that immigrants experience in reality. The story is primarily an aspirational tale, and the overall mood is one of hope. Needless to say, this is one that mitigates some of the negative consequences of personal displacement. There is no fear and hate in the New World. There is just some culture shock, temporary unemployment, and the drudgery of working in menial factory-based assembly line production. This makes the story less than totally convincing to adult readers. Some will probably find it a naive fantasy. But in choosing to concentrate on the personal rather than the political, Tan focuses on the transformative nature of the immigrant experience - Every person is in search for something better for themselves and their loved ones. Is it wrong to want that? Conveying this message to today's younger audience may actually be a better answer than writing a more vitriolic work. Maybe...
9/03/2010
Draw Muhammed Day
![]() |
| Go to: Muhammad Ali, The Champ by Michael Gaffney Muhammad Ali at Angelo Dundee's, Fifth Street Gym, Miami, FL More photos at Proud |
9/01/2010
Batman feels...
![]() |
| By Nate Bellegarde Go to: Theme Sketchbook: Batman Getting Hit in the Balls from Justin Stewart |
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






































