3/05/2010

Disappearance Diary

Disappearance Diary by Hideo Azuma.
Reading Disappearance Diary by veteran creator Hideo Azuma immediately brought to mind the omake that occupy the very end of manga collections or the margins of manga pages. Most manga (the ones that get translated) are formula driven entertainment; so the omake are a way for creators to inject a personal element to their own works. These tend to be light and breezy in tone and usually reveal trivial details about the creator's personal life. Sometimes this produces some dissonance between the omake and the actual story, such as in the latter half of the series Kare Kano: the harrowing events the characters experience are disconcertingly juxtaposed with creator Masami Tsuda's pointless chatter about her tastes in classical music or her obsessions with Japanese cuisine. By contrast Disappearance Diary feels in some ways like an extended omake: Drawn in a cute, halfway super-deformed style, the story consistently maintains a detached sense of humor even as it narrates the sordid details of Azuma's increasingly out-of-control life.

This deliberate choice to see the funny side of life begins with Azuma's own botched attempt at a suicide. The results as depicted are comic rather than tragic. The book then recounts the three stages of Azuma's downward spiral of self-destructive behavior: Twice when he attempted to drop off the grid, and his descent into alcoholism. Like an omake or yonkoma, the story is rambling and episodic in structure as its focus is on minutiae of what it's like to be homeless, or the rehabilitation process of an alcoholic. The book's cute version of Azuma is like the castaway who learns to survive by mastering important life skills such as dumpster-diving or acquiring protection against the elements. After a while, the grimier aspects of living day-by-day fall away. Every little triumph pushes the reader to become more invested in his survival and welfare. The second time he runs off, he even gets a new job and acquires new skills as a pipe fitter. Of course it was his decision to live in this manner; but it's a lot easier to empathize with a short, cuddly, cartoon character than a smelly, middle-aged, homeless man. That's the power of moe for you.

Disappearance Diary by Hideo Azuma.
But when Azuma declares "This manga has a positive outlook on life and so it has been made with as much realism removed as possible..." what he leaves out is just as telling because it draws attention to a gaping hole in the narrative. Azuma doesn't go into great detail about the depression itself that caused him to run off. That would put a damper on the mood. Azuma simply avoids wallowing in his dark side to maintain his stated aesthetic goal of removing realism. But most perturbing is how he goes out of his way to avoid discussing the impact his actions have on other people. He does briefly acknowledge its negative effects on his colleagues and apologizes to his editors. But he's circumspect about the trouble it caused his family. His adventures with homelessness ends when the police arrest him and return him to his family. But these are glossed over "because none of this was funny." Later when he's rehabbing at a hospital, he worries that his wife will divorce him. These statements are made more provocative because they are made so rarely and tossed out so casually in the book. Azuma's sounds like he's aware of the hurt he's caused. He just doesn't want to talk about it. But those are the really interesting bits people would be curious to know more about.

Disappearance Diary by Hideo Azuma.
What Azuma's doing is bucking certain conventions. Considering the serious subject matter, most readers would expect from autobiographical works a good deal of introspection or self-flagellation; even a moment of epiphany when the protagonist realizes how low he's sunk as a prelude to his road to redemption. That doesn't happen here. When Disappearance Diary ends, Azuma is still muddling his way through rehab. He's amusing and observant, but not necessarily any more emotionally aware than when he first arrived at the hospital. In short there's no catharsis at the end; and this will undoubtedly displease some readers. They will find the book version of Azuma morally repugnant. By sidestepping the more unpleasant details of his closest relationships, he still comes across just as big a jerk than if he went the opposite way and whined nonstop about his difficult life. It's hard not to be seen in a negative light when someone abandons his wife and kid. But the tactic serves to capture a character not fully recovered and still very much in denial.

A rather fascinating section of the book is when he goes off on a tangent and summarizes his entire career up to that point. Azuma is one of those important manga figures that's never received much attention abroad. As someone only vaguely aware of his reputation, his listing of his numerous manga projects is frustrating because it requires some familiarity with his work to understand him. Nonetheless there are some interesting tidbits of information about the enormous pressures placed on professional manga creators. There's also this one panel where he recounts a collaboration to create a lolicon-themed fanzine with the intent to "drive yaoi out of Comiket" that alludes to dueling subcultures. I'm not sure how seriously to take the battle cry, but it raises all kinds of interesting questions about the differing fetishes of male and female fans in Japan; and leads back to Azuma's own individual hang-ups as the leading popularizer of the lolicon sub-genre.

Disappearance Diary by Hideo Azuma.
Despite the problematic decision to treat a memoir about a particularly low point of his life as a lighthearted humor strip, Disappearance Diary is still in some ways a compelling read. It's probably compelling because of that odd decision.

2/21/2010

More NonSense: Established Media

DC LOGO.

This week's news was dominated by the corporate reshuffling at DC Entertainment. Outgoing publisher Paul Levitz was replaced by five people: Dan DiDio and Jim Lee - co-publishers of DC Comics; Geoff Johns - chief creative officer of DCE; John Rood - executive vice president-sales, marketing and business development; and Patrick Caldon - executive vice president-finance and administration. They report to new president Diane Nelson. With the exception of Rood, Nelson chose to promote existing DC employees. Dirk Deppey has link roundup.

Caldon explains what should be taken away from this announcement:
Today’s announcement signals change, but change that comes with continuity. Familiar faces (Dan and Jim and Geoff) and familiar people behind the scenes ... are joined by new faces (Diane and John). It’s a dynamic team, one with an eye on the future and an appreciation for the past.
We'll see whether that's true in the coming months.

Gary Groth finally responds to the complaints about tcj.com, begun by no less than their own Noah Berlatsky, by announcing some design and personal changes. Noah initially criticized the site's weak design last year before moving on to attacking Groth's self-congratulatory intro to the relaunched site. Noah took exception to Groth's air of superiority towards bloggers - a typical stance of print journalists towards online writing:
Another way people often denigrate blogging, I think, is by suggesting that it’s not as concentrated, or thoughtful, or ambitious as writing a book. Again, it’s true that ambitious blogs don’t look like ambitious books, but I don’t think the difference is necessarily one of quality or thoughtfulness per se. As a blogger, I’m currently in the process of writing at length about every single issue of the Marston/Peter Wonder Woman run. Economically, that’s simply not something you could do in print. Similarly, a collaborative work of criticism like Tom Spurgeon’s massive series of holiday interviews on comics of the decade would be much, much more difficult to organize in a print magazine than online.
Not surprisingly, there's been some schadenfreude from the online community over tcj.com's teething problems after Groth's remarks. As Johanna Draper Carlson points out:
If Groth wants to slam online work for being “amateurish, shallow, frivolous” (as he did as a site welcome, a badly chosen introduction if ever there was one) and think that they’re going to show all those bloggers how things should be done… well, the contrast between those intentions and the actual site should be in the dictionary as the most obvious example of “hubris” I’ve seen in a while. Gary, your baby was out-of-date before it launched. Your contempt for online work shows through in the lack of effort put in here, with the site ignoring common best practices apparently through ignorance that there even were such things.
As someone who read the Journal in print (whenever I could find copies), I'm still pretty hopeful for its new online incarnation. But it's many ways a johnny-come-lately to the fast changing World Wide Web; and its print history doesn't automatically translate into online appeal as other established gatekeepers of older media have learned to their chagrin.

Whatever its problems, the site deserves praise for gathering some of the brightest bloggers on the web. For example, R. Fiore has written an excellent post comparing Worldcon (World Science Fiction Convention) and CCI (Comic Con International). The former was once the larger convention. But the latter outgrew the former by leaps and bounds because it adapted to changes in popular culture, while Worldcon stagnated and now only appeals to the hardcore crowd. Of course lots of fans now complain about the changes to CCI.

In other news:

Cindy Au summarizes the reactions to The Last Airbender Super Bowl ad (More on Avatar Racebending).

Michael Murphey, CEO of iVerse Media; Jeff Webber, director of ePublishing for IDW Publishing; Brett Dovman, CFO of PanelFly, and writer Andy Ihanatko, debate the proper format and presentation for digital comics at Macworld 2010. There's also a separate video interview with Ihanatko where he relates his year-long experiment to consume comics and other media exclusively in digital forms. The results for comics were dismal if someone were to avoid BitTorrent. I get the feeling he doesn't read manga.

The Yes Men attend the offsite TED Conference and discover that anti-corporate activism isn't cool there.

2/20/2010

Wonder Woman #40

Wonder Woman #40: The Crows
The last time I reviewed the current Wonder Woman, she was battling the forces of darkness in the form of evil doppelgänger Genocide - a creation of war god Ares. That turned out to be part of a larger plan to destroy the Amazon nation. The chaos that created provided cover for Ares to impregnate a couple of Amazons. Divinely conceived children grow up so fast; so it wasn't long before they graduated to terrorizing the DC population with their creepy mind control powers. They're an obvious homage to the The Midwich Cuckoos, except in this issue they're referred to as the Crows.

Wonder Woman #40: Serpent God
They also continue the recent fad of victimizing the gods of other pantheons by inducing a Meso-American feathered serpent to swallow some commuters. But Wonder Woman easily defeats the wayward god. It's a basic rampaging monster smackdown to establish the hero's credentials. Penciller Aaron Lopresti gets to show off his creature design skills yet again, which doesn't change my opinion from the last review. But for writer Gail Simone, Diana is different breed from the usual ass kicker: First she beats you up; then she talks you to her side. So Diana shows concern for both the serpent god and its regurgitated victims. This is also the DC universe where WW, labeled as one of the big three, is supposably deified to ludicrous levels. Even a little skepticism from the public is treated as a major crisis. So the Crows naturally start working on undermining her reputation. Didn't she once get a lot of flack for killing a villain in self defense? I guess people have moved on.

Wonder Woman #40: Etta Candy
The in-universe perspective hasn't always reflected her real world treatment. But Simone loves WW's history. As with Superman and Batman, the reverence can be pretty annoying. But it's made a bit more palatable by old school fan service. Giving Diana a squad of super-powered apes bought back some Silver Age wackiness to the title. Bringing back supporting characters Etta Candy and Steve Trevor was another fan pleasing move. Etta in particular has imparted some much needed levity since her reintroduction as loyal sidekick; and the centerpiece of this issue is an explanation for her suddenly improved fighting abilities. There's also a lot of personal affirmation of sisterhood; something missing in previous recent interpretations of the character. But fan service works both ways. One moment WW's bonding with her best friend; next she's being pummeled by a clearly enchanted Power Girl - DC's walking plot device for angry irrational female superhero. The reader will have to wait till next issue to see how WW will talk her out of that spell.

2/14/2010

Imaginary Asians

The latest trailer for the upcoming movie The Last Airbender aired as a Super Bowl ad last weekend. Here's the part that shows the Southern Water Tribe with main characters Sokka and Katara front and center:

Frame from the The Last Airbender trailor.

And here's a still from the animated series that inspired the movie:

Frame from Avatar The Last Airbender.

This has given more ammunition to critics of the film's casting choices. Two Caucasian actors (Jackson Rathbone and Nicola Peltz) surrounded by a supporting cast from different ethnicities. Racebending.com has compared this scene to Earl Derr Biggers playing the Asian hero of the Charlie Chan movies of the 1930s.
Eighty years later and still people of color are only allowed in the background. An entire tribe populated using extras from Greenland – a nation that is almost 90% of Inuit heritage – is championed by two Caucasians.

Chan was conceived at the time as a progressive alternative to the Yellow Peril stereotype; but not so progressive that he could be played by an actual Asian person. The Avatar The Last Airbender series doesn't self-consciously portray Asians in opposition to a particular negative preconception, and its treatment of racial issues is rather broad. But the casting choices of its film adaptation not only dredges up Hollywood's long history with Yellowface and the more recent whitewashing of foreign properties, but highlights the problematic nature of translating any animated property to live action.

Despite recent technological advances that allow animators to realistically render characters in three dimensions, most animation still utilizes a relatively simpler "freestyle" manner (to adopt a term from R. Fiore). This has the advantage of allowing for enormous expressive range by using relatively simple linear renditions. But it's also a double-edged sword. What can be magnified isn't just emotions, but physical characteristics. Since the artist decides the characteristics to be rendered, this tends to reflect what the artist perceives as important. When the artist is influenced by particular racial attitudes, the end result can be a portrayal that exaggerates what are in reality only minor differences between individuals. Cartoonists influenced by the Blackface theatrical tradition drew people of African descent with large googly eyes, disproportionately thick lips, and exceedingly dark skin. Those influenced by Yellow Peril tend to depict Asians with narrow eyes and sallow skin. In Japanese manga, it's not uncommon to draw Westerners as tall, clumsy, and blond-haired. This isn't a simple East vs. West thing: It's also not unusual for mangaka to draw Korean characters with stronger "ethnic" characteristics when interacting with Japanese characters.

Emma and Otoyomegatari by Kaoru Mori.
Western European and Central Asian characters from mangaka Kaoru Mori's historically-based fiction.

However it would be a mistake to imagine that all cartoonists are interested in highlighting racial differences. On the contrary, cartoonists can often use a detail-oriented "liberal" approach that can still appear ambiguous. This ambiguity can often lead to confusion and misunderstanding when the audience doesn't understand the conventions that the artist is following. The most obvious example is the “Why do they look Caucasian?” question raised by an audience unfamiliar to Japanese manga conventions. To the Japanese the characters are not necessarily white, but they end up looking so to many Westerners applying their particular expectations to the Japanese market. To quote critic and translator Matt Thorn:
...Non-Europeans living in a European-dominated society absorb these standards themselves, and not only are continuously made to be aware of their “otherness,” but adhere, out of necessity, to the Eurocentric system of signification. If an American of Asian descent wants to create a children’s book intended to build self-esteem among Asian American children and educate other children about Asian American experiences, she must first make sure the readers know that the characters represented are Asian, and so, consciously or not, she resorts to stereotyped signifiers that are easily recognizable, such as “slanted” eyes (an exaggerated representation of the epicanthic fold that is often, but not always, more pronounced in East Asians than in Europeans or Africans) or pitch black, straight hair (regardless of the fact that East Asian hair can range from near-black to reddish brown, and is often wavy or even frizzy). So it is that Americans and others raised in European-dominated societies, regardless of their background, will see a circle with two dots for eyes and a line for a mouth, free of racial signifiers, as “white.”

...Japan, however, is not and never has been a European-dominated society. The Japanese are not Other within their own borders, and therefore drawn (or painted or sculpted) representations of, by and for Japanese do not, as a rule, include stereotyped racial markers. A circle with two dots for eyes and a line for a mouth is, by default, Japanese.

Tails by Ethan Young.
Webcomics creator Ethan Young alters his art in order to clarify his characters ethnicity. Before (left), After (right). Link by Sean Kleefeld.

Avatar is drawn in a style that largely avoids the abuse of exaggerated racial markers; hence the confusion about their ethnic identities. But another aspect of Avatar that is often used by people who defend the casting choices is the fictional nature of the original series. Co-creators Michael DiMartino and Bryan Konietzko have often credited their Asian influences in every aspect of the series design. But the world they create isn't "real" in the literal sense (adopting Fiore): There are no historically authentic Chinese, Japanese, Indians, Inuit, Koreans etc. that inhabit Avatar. And because Avatar is a fictionalized, romanticized and simplified version of Asian culture and history, there are people who feel that they can literally insert a Caucasian presence into it since the series sidesteps the need for historical accuracy. As far as they're concerned, two white guys imagined this, so what's the harm?

Avatar the Last Airbender.
The core characters of the first season of Avatar: The Last Airbender.

Alternate timelines are a staple in many fantasy stories. Many of the most popular Japanese imports are alternate worlds. Take the megahit Fullmetal Alchemist by Hiromu Arakawa. It's largely set in a nation called Amestris that's modeled after early industrial Europe and Weimar era Germany. The country is in conflict with its neighbors, including the vaguely Middle-Eastern Ishbalans. Are the Amestrians white? Or more specifically German? Given the style of cartooning, the answer isn't immediately obvious except to people who see manga characters as Caucasian. But looking at the fictional culture they inhabit, there are some pretty strong signifiers for their Western identities: They have Western names; they read and write using Roman characters; they sport Western style clothing; They inhabit European style buildings. So yes, they are imagined Europeans from an alternate universe. But Arakawa is free to incorporate Japanese-style elements into his fantasy world. Anyone very familiar with shonen manga can identify them: The struggle to become stronger; the concept of nakama; the sempai-kohai relationship; a particular attitude to pacifism vs. war. Even alchemy, the story's most publicized element, is fitted to become a mystical form of hand-to-hand combat not unlike the quan-fa inspired bending arts of Avatar. The Elric brothers alchemy is superficially similar to earth bending. To readers of the original manga, they speak Japanese. In the animated adaptation, they sound Japanese.

Fullmetal Alchemist
Amestrian characters of Fullmetal Alchemist.

A similar thing is happening with Avatar. The world is largely a blend of classical Asian elements. The characters posses Asian sounding names; they read and write with Chinese characters; they sport Asian styled fashions; they inhabit buildings that are a fusion of Eastern styles; they know kung fu (sigh...) So yeah, they're Asian, albeit through a fantasy world. But its co-creators freely blend Western elements into the series: The story's slapstick humor, timing, rhythms, and characterizations are more Western than Eastern. While the voice cast is fairly multi-ethnic, the characters all speak with an American patois that would sound anachronistic in a period story. The most touted narrative element of the series (and most vulnerable to accusations of ethnic stereotyping) is the concept of bending, which is organized according to the four categories of Western alchemy.

But the most relevant feauture of Avatar is that it's a Western-style fantasy epic about the struggle against totalitarianism - an aspect of the superhero genre since World War II, and a component of any fantasy that mimics Lord of the Rings. Avatar sidesteps the skin color-defined racial struggle between Caucasians vs. everyone else, found in J.R.R. Tolkien, by inventing a pan-Asian world. Instead of skin color, race is defined more as spirituality manifested by the four nations in their respective bending arts. The most technologically advanced nation (and most Western?) wages a war of conquest based on the idea of its own superiority of its culture to the more "primitive" cultures. This is demonstrated in their rejection of Avatar Aang - a supernatural entity who embodies a mélange of ideas about spiritual wisdom,  harmonious balance, and universal peace. As the main protagonist of the series, Aang combines tropes about Eastern mysticism with that of a conventional action hero - he's a Buddhist saint who kicks ass.

Bryan Konietzko poster
Detail of a Bryan Konietzko poster created after the onset of the casting controversy. The character Aang suddenly acquires stronger Asian features. Photo from flickr.

The loose non-literal style used by most animated serials combined with the  metaphorical inventiveness of fantasy make it easy to create a flexible blend of cultural elements. There is of course an unavoidable commercial aspect to this formula. Even the most exotic imaginary world benefits from characters that the native audience can identify with enough to pay to watch or read about. But no matter how inventive the creators, they can't completely escape their own skin. There's an undeniable viewpoint informed by the creators native background that I think sometimes glibly romanticizes and stereotypes foreign cultures under the heading of fantasy world-building. But as long as these fantasy characters remain cartoons, pinning down their exact ethnic identity isn't exactly an urgent issue, and ultimately beside the point to enjoying the story.

The problem however comes when the cartoon transitions into live action: The literal invades and changes the equation. The actors who play the parts will posses actual ethnic backgrounds, which have political complications. What was loose and ambiguous suddenly becomes concrete and rigid. Thanks to a casting choice decision, Sokka's and Katara's American twang and other mannerisms were given precedence over all the other things that identify them as Asian. And apparently in Hollywood, the default for American is white. But the trailor indicates that the actors who play their immediate family, relatives, and clan members, are people of color. Not surprisingly, this is being justified as a form of multicultarism, and ironically also excused under the pretense of fantasy world-building. While in an ideal post-racial world it would be possible to cast an actor for any part regardless of ethnic identity, in this world the entertainment industry's history of racial discrimination are an inescapable reality. So while Paramount's actions towards the casting conform to standard operating procedure, it would inevitably clash with some of the series more devoted fans who may, or may not, have initially given the issue much thought.

More on Avatar Racebending

2/11/2010

Siege #1-2

Siege by Brian Michael Bendis, Chris Eliopoulos, Laura Martin, Mark Morales, Oliver Coipel.Siege by Brian Michael Bendis, Chris Eliopoulos, Laura Martin, Mark Morales, Oliver Coipel.

by Brian Michael Bendis, Chris Eliopoulos, Laura Martin, Mark Morales, Oliver Coipel

It's a hallmark of the Marvel Universe that its characters have to fight hard just to maintain an even keel. Even on their best days, Marvel's superheroes face a world that fears and loathes them. At least that's the general idea Marvel wants to convey anyway. But as anyone who's been paying attention to its company-wide events for the last three years, its superhero in-universe stock has been dropping rapidly. They've been outlawed, arrested, identities publicly exposed, murdered, kidnapped, impersonated, and suffered the indignity of watching their mortal enemies being put into key positions of power. Eventually this downward spiral had to reverse itself before it alienated even Marvel's most diehard fans. Which leads to the latest company-wide event Siege.

For an event that is much hyped as the culmination of several years of storytelling, the main Siege miniseries, which is currently halfway through its four issue run, is a fairly pedestrian effort. While it's easy to blame writer Brian Michael Bendis, Siege is, like most events, a part of a much larger commercial package designed to appeal to hardcore fans and completists. The miniseries functions as a spine from which the reader attaches several interconnected titles. The fact that it has become SOP for Marvel to supply the checklist for company-wide events just to keep the story straight is not only a sign of the kind of mental and financial investment required by the reader, but also how much synergy is required between at least half a dozen writers. The miniseries is a gigantic spectacle and little else. Presumably the subsidiary titles are there to supply a additional narrative substance. But the result is that the central story lacks any context or emotional pull to its proceedings.

Siege Issue #1

The setup is simple enough to those who've been following Marvel: über-villain Norman Osborne has spent his time accumulating political capital while successfully discrediting any effective opposition from the superhero community. Now he decides to eliminate the Asgardians, who for reasons too complicated to go into, have relocated Asgard above Oklahoma. With the help of evil god Loki, he engineers an incident as a pretense to launch a full-scale invasion of Asgard with all the military and superhumans under his command. In what is either an act of symmetry or just lazy writing, the incident mimics the one that sparked Civil War. But while Mark Millar used Civil War as a platform to deliver ham fisted political messages, Bendis plays it straight. While Iron Man and Captain America fighting over superhero rights in the former pretended to be relevant, here Osborne is clearly in the wrong, necessitating the intervention of Thor and the real Avengers. It couldn't be any more obvious if Bendis had Osborne and Loki cackle maniacally. So in place of ponderous discussions on whether superheroes do more harm than good, we have a perfunctory scene that barely registers the death of thousands of civilians, followed by several scenes of Osborne cowing, bribing, and lying his way in order to commit an act of genocide. Osborne has never had much dealings with the Asgardians in the past; so his motivations for listening to Loki and attacking them seem like an empty exercise in rote villain behavior.

Siege Issue #1

The battle of Asgard proceeds at a similarly clipped pace: Thor is quickly taken down; Ares and Balder have a brief exchange; a B-lister dies to stress just how evil Osborne is; Steve Rogers rallies the superheroes driven underground by Osborne. The art supplied by Oliver Coipel and company is fairly conventional, but slickly drawn. There are some pretty splash pages, but overall the backgrounds and surface details are rather generic and kept to a minimum. Unfortunately this doesn't help convey the sense of scale needed for these grandiose battle set pieces.

Siege feels very much like a means to an end - to establish a new status quo. The first issue cover already promises the triumphant reunion of Thor, Iron Man, and Captain America. If it does that while ending Norman Osborne's reign of terror, it may be the cathartic experience many fans want. But as a story in itself, the miniseries is a rather stilted excuse to justify one big fight.

Siege Issue #2

When Nerds Challenge Jocks


Fedor Emelianenko let them off easy

1/30/2010

Miscellaneous

Rob Reger, “creator” (if it were ever appropriate to put extra scare quotes around a word, this would be the time) of Emily the Strange, is another of the big success stories. He’s built a multi-million-dollar empire, including a series of comic books (that’s right, I’m keeping this on topic) on a single illustration lifted directly from the awesome Nate the Great children’s books–and when the real creators started asking stores not to carry Emily the Strange merchandise, Reger sued them. Balls. That’s how you get ahead in this business.

- Shaenon Garrity

The weird thing is that Sim has spent the past ten years or so, ever since the drugs ate his brain for good, going on and on about how much he abhors all things feminine. Yet his first project, post-misogynistic-heel-turn, is an effortful, not especially vicious pastiche of the most stereotypically feminine pop-cult extrusion he can find. More than anything, Sim’s work on Glamourpuss reminds me of those evangelical Christian guys who go “undercover” at gay pride events across the country so they can take photos and report breathlessly on all the terrible, terrible sodomy on display... Everybody knows these guys are gay. Even their congregations know. What I’m saying, I guess, is that Glamourpuss would be more fun if Sim would just admit that he’s honestly fascinated by the stuff he claims to be satirizing or exposing or whatever. If he’d come clean about loving shoes, makeup and blowjob tips as much as he loves Alex Raymond illustrations, we could have an awesome comic, or whatever it is, here.

- Shaenon Garrity

More NonSense: Tablet Edition

Apple iPad.
 The thing that bothers me most about the iPad is this: if I had an iPad rather than a real computer as a kid, I’d never be a programmer today. I’d never have had the ability to run whatever stupid, potentially harmful, hugely educational programs I could download or write. I wouldn’t have been able to fire up ResEdit and edit out the Mac startup sound so I could tinker on the computer at all hours without waking my parents. The iPad may be a boon to traditional education, insofar as it allows for multimedia textbooks and such, but in its current form, it’s a detriment to the sort of hacker culture that has propelled the digital economy. - Alex Payne
the iPad appeals to a very deep and longlived fantasy in the consumer electronics world: A device that does it all. At least, if all you want to do is consume media... [it] has all the problems of television, with none of the benefits of computers. - Annalee Newitz

Love 'em or hate 'em (There's not a whole lot of room for in-between), you just can't ignore 'em. Which is why Apple's revealing of the iPad tablet is still a "game changer" in the sense that it's already forcing its competitors to rethink their own future offerings.

I don't have a whole lot to say about the iPad's possible impact on the publishing business, or print comics in particular. My own initial reaction to it was along the lines of "iPod 3.0". This was a predictable and logical next step. The launch of the iPod marked a shift at Apple from personal computer manufacturer to consumer media facilitator. As someone who grew up with the former, the iPad isn't something I need: It's not very customizable; it doesn't run Photoshop or Lightroom or The Gimp; it doesn't use a pen or mouse. In short it's not the Cintiq alternative we graphics artists have long desired. It mystifies me, even though I know it shouldn't, that some people harbored unrealistic expectations that the iPad would be just that. But as a consumer device, it's a natural expansion of Apple's media offerings (music, photos, video, mail, web, voice, and now print). In fact, it's the most sedentary media device yet from Apple.
Penny Arcade by  Jerry Holkins and Mike Krahulik.

Now, it's predecessors the iPod and the iPhone (iPod 2.0) faced fierce criticism when they were launched. And those criticisms, interestingly, carry over to the iPad. Some of these have, at their core, existed since the time hackers complained about the original Macintosh. And yet Apple has found the right combination of feature-set, "magic", and marketing to convince consumers to inhabit their tightly controlled ecosystem. For better or worse, most of them seem to be okay with it. Apple's hoping to extend its success into the e-reader market. The iPad gambit could easily fail. The economy isn't in the best shape right now. There is the issue of the potential market size for tablets vs netbooks that could make the iPad a tough sell. Will the feature/price-set be still attractive to customers when its finally made available? And there is the question of the content offerings in the iBooks store. The biggest unanswered question underlying the success or failure of the iPad and its competitors is what is the killer app, or principal function, that will draw customers to tablets. Will it be the consumption of e-books and other media, or something entirely different that none of the players anticipated? But it also wouldn't surprise me if Apple leverages the existing iPhone market to somehow pull it of a third time; confounding critics and rivals yet again; opening up a new market; and even managing to convince some consumers to spend $800+ upsell on a tablet of all things that could drop in price at its next iteration.
Netbooks aren’t better at anything. They are slow, they have low-quality displays and run... PC software... [The iPad] is so much more intimate than a laptop, and so much more capable than a smartphone with this gorgeous large display. - Steve Jobs

If given the choice, it's a no-brainer to pick the iPad over the iPhone/iPod and netbook to read the average comics page. Speaking as a "tablet" user, I prefer its form factor for comfortable reading to the standard laptop. And for all the fretting over its limitations, I think it's premature to claim that the device will snuff-out technological innovation, open standards, personal creativity, or artistic expression, vis-a-vis other mass media delivery systems. Apple's certainly not going to be able to prevent many smart people from hacking the iPad after its release. The company's more vehement critics are just as prone to give it too much credit as its hardcore fans.

Jorge Colombo iPhone drawings.

In the meantime, I'll stick with my Cintiq while I'm waiting for the portable graphics tablet of my dreams.

PS: 
Many people spend all day working in front of a computer, and they simply don’t like the idea of coming home to yet another computer that looks just like the one they use at work.

Just to comment on Daniel Tenner's post -  My not so computer-literate mom was the first to broach the topic of the iPad the day it was revealed to the public. To my mild surprise, she suddenly announced that she would buy one when it became available. It appealed to her as a reading device, and she's not in love with the laptop she uses for email and web browsing. So based on purely anecdotal evidence, I guess there's something to the argument that the tablet could be the uncomputer for the rest of us.

1/28/2010

Joe the Barbarian #1

Joe the Barbarian by Grant Morrison, Sean Murphy, Todd Klein, Dave Stewart.
by Grant Morrison, Sean Murphy, Todd Klein, Dave Stewart.

"Every Town has them. Every school has them. Stereotypes...What do I look like?" proclaims the eponymous hero of Joe the Barbarian. Given that this is a Grant Morrison comic, one wonders if that statement is a prelude to future metafictional hijinks. That's because this inaugural issue is pretty straightforward and easily approachable. Joe is your typically alienated teenager with an absent father (he's conveniently dead), and an emotionally unavailable mother (she's too busy trying to keep a roof over their head to meaningfully communicate with her son). Joe's artistic talent earns him the usual casual bullying, with requisite gay bashing, from the school's redneck crowd. He's also suffering from some chronic illness that demands regular medication. Joe is so self-involved he doesn't  even acknowledge the one female classmate who's nice to him. This is as familiar a collection of cliches found in any teen drama; and a font of inspiration of many a Stan Lee-created Marvel series.

Equally familiar is the premise of the awkward teen being drawn into a fantasy-fueled world were the protagonist can get to play the hero he isn't in the mundane world (for comparison, check out this xkcd strip). But this is a Vertigo title written by the writer of past titles like The Invisibles and The Filth. That could mean some bizarre genre twisting somewhere down the road. I don't know. What is obvious for now is that Joe is a huge geek, and his fantasy world is populated by full sized versions of his action figure collection. It's a motley crew of every old-school male geek passions: furry teddy bears, military types,  superheroes, sci-fi characters, and Japanese mecha. This world may or may not be the byproduct of his illness.

Joe The Barbarian #1 page 8

Unlike the hyper-compressed Final Crisis, Morrison contributes little in the way of narrative text. Most of the exposition is handled by his artistic partners. Sean Murphy and Dave Stewart supply many silent panels with richly detailed and moody backgrounds. Murphy is particularly adept at capturing the rather awkward body language of adolescents. At the center of this issue is a four page sequence of Joe entering his house and passing room after room until he finally ascends up to his attic bedroom which is cluttered with all his toys. It very effectively conveys the character's self-imposed isolation from everyone around him.  Morrison simply underlines this sentiment with a few terse statements ending with "This is my room. This is my house." It's rather easy to see how Joe can slip into a private fantasy world when ensconced in his room; assuming that his fantasies are just pure make believe. Whatever the case, Murphy and Stewart effectively illustrate the transition between the two worlds.

At this point there's not much to indicate how the story will handle the tension between mundane vs fantasy. As a first issue, its purpose is to raise questions that leave the reader hungry for the answers. While not entirely original at this stage, Joe the Barbarian is intriguing enough to at least stick around for the next issue.

Joe The Barbarian #1 page 16

1/25/2010

Luna Park

Luna Park by Kevin Baker, Danijel Zezelj, Dave Stewart, Jared Fletcher.
by Kevin Baker, Danijel Zezelj, Dave Stewart, Jared Fletcher.

Kevin Baker is the latest in a line of established writers from other fields who have used their reputations to break into comics. The resulting work, Luna Park, reflects his novelistic backgrounds in several ways: The subject matter is similar to the Coney Island setting of his book Dreamland (Thank you Wikipedia). The story is told with words in the third person by an omniscient narrator. The book's self contained narrative is complex and ambitious. The timeline shifts constantly back and forth between the present, several historical periods, and the dreamtime of myth and legend. Roughly two thirds in, the story suddenly mutates to expand on its central themes. It's an arresting section that upends the entire book. But the "gotcha" ending falls flat and doesn't quite succeed in holding everything together.

Alik Strelnikov is a Russian ex-soldier and veteran of the Chechen war who now works as an enforcer for a petty criminal organization based in Coney Island. But he knows it's only a matter of time before his boss is overrun by a more powerful rival. In the meantime he's haunted not just by the memory of the tragic events that led to him leaving the army and emigrating to America; but also by old Russian tales. The story in Aleksandr Pushkin's poem The Bronze Horseman in particular is almost as significant to him as the events in his life. The only thing Alik has to look forward to is the company of Marina - a fortuneteller/prostitute who works for another mobster. Whether in his dingy apartment or wondering the desolate Coney Island landscape; together they try to recapture the innocence of childhood through heroin and alcohol induced reveries.

Luna Park by Kevin Baker, Danijel Zezelj, Dave Stewart, Jared Fletcher.

If the reader is expecting a tragic crime noir where the participants best laid plans come to naught;  the cycle of violence remains unbroken; and men are ultimately betrayed by women despite the best intentions; that's what happens for the first two thirds of the story. Alik is a broken idealist still yearning for the quiet life denied to him even as experience has taught him to be skeptical of human nature. Baker is a seasoned storyteller ably partnered with artist Danijel Zezelj. His expressionistic style holds its own next to Baker's robust text. Under his capable hands Coney Island is portrayed with a certain gloomy state of decay and disrepair. It looks photo referenced, but never stiff. I'm less impressed with colorist Dave Stewart's typically muddy Vertigo palette.

Just as Alik and Marina's story is about to reach its inevitable conclusion, the book takes an unexpected turn towards metafiction. Reality fades away and story becomes the new reality. The tale of two lowlifes morphs into the sordid history of Russia with Alik and Marina revealed as recurring archetypes of hope, love, and betrayal. Alik's story becomes his father's; then his grandfather's; and then the story of the bronze horseman trampling on his hapless peasant victims. The history of violence extends back to Mongol invaders and Russia's mythical rulers and forward to the heart of Washington DC. Baker is reaching  for something epochal. But in doing so he renders his main characters insignificant in the last third of the book. That is arguably the point of Luna Park. Less convincing though is the theme that many of the events in Russian history are all part of some grand recurring pattern. It's easy enough when Baker is writing about Alik's family. But he's on shakier ground when he tries to find a connecting thread between historical events. Yes history is full of violence and bloodshed; but is that all there is? Are all Russians doomed to be crushed by the weight of their own history? It's such a generic insight. And the final example which ends the book feels too forced to be a convincing example.

Luna Park by Kevin Baker, Danijel Zezelj, Dave Stewart, Jared Fletcher.

I feel that Luna Park fails because the ending overreaches. The marriage of crime fiction and sweeping historical drama never quite gels. And for all the talents of its creators, It is ultimately a dreary book to read that fritters away any investment the readers might have on its characters.

1/14/2010

Hellboy: The Wild Hunt

Hellboy #37-44

by Mike Mignola, Duncan Fegredo, Clem Robins, Dave Stewart

In the tradition of the best geeky, superhero comics storytelling, Hellboy meshes disparate elements together into a grandiose action adventure tale: The eponymous hero is always fighting a varied menagerie that included Nazi agents, Japanese vampires, European werewolves, or Lovecraftian alien monsters. But like many serials begun in the late nineties, it is framed by a larger story arc: In those early stories there was already a sense that there was more going on. Creator Mike Mignola took those monster-fighting episodes as far as he could before setting his protagonist free to explore his place in the larger cosmos. With Hellboy: The Wild Hunt, this phase of the character's development seems to be over as he's forced to make a choice between the various factions determined to start a war that could possibly destroy the world. The story is the latest in a series of revelations beginning with The Island that answers many previous unexplained elements; outlines the history of the universe Hellboy inhabits; and reveals his role within it. Mignola finally seems to have finished preparations for the presumably climactic end of the series.

Hellboy The Wild Hunt 8 pg 15

As with the previous Darkness Calls, the linework is by Duncan Fegredo. I sometimes miss Mignola's visuals, but Fregredo is a more than capable replacement. He's able to duplicate Mignola's angular character designs and idiosyncratic chiaroscuro; but his style is more realistically detailed; and his panels far more panoramic. While Mignola's backgrounds would progressively become more pared down and abstract, Fegredo uses establishing shots and often pulls back from the characters to illustrate the larger physical setting. Fegredo excels at highlighting interior details e.g. the underground passage of the Wild Hunt filled with decapitated giant heads; or the mysterious floating knights found in Morgan le Fay's castle.

Hellboy The Wild Hunt 1 pg 12

It's fortuitous that Fegredo took over as the primary artist when the series began to concentrate on certain female characters. The Wild Hunt deals with the aftermath of Hellboy's conflict with Baba Yaga and the witches in Darkness Calls; and his ongoing conflict with Hecate. In The Wild Hunt, Fegredo gets to portray three pivotal characters in Hellboy's development: The queenly Morgan le Fay; her adversary Nimue; and the adult version of Alice - last seen way back as a baby in the The Corpse. Fegredo imbues them with a physical presence usually not found in Mignola's character renditions. The villanous Nimue is a gloomy figure cloaked in perpetual shadow; Morgan carries herself with a certain inherent nobility that belies her evil reputation; while Alice possesses a down to earth charm that sets her apart from the other Hellboy characters. Her addition to the cast has the effect of softening Hellboy's typically reserved machismo. Her influence allows Hellboy to take positive action.

Hellboy The Wild Hunt 3 pg 2

The Wild Hunt marks a first step past the emotional conflict between the human and demonic sides that has often paralyzed Hellboy. From the beginning he's been beset by hints that he is the Beast from Revelations that will bring about the end of the world. When he left his surrogate family at the BPRD, the knowledge he gained only cast him further adrift. Morgan supplies Hellboy (and the reader) with a dizzying amount of detail about his Arthurian heritage; which helps fill in some important plot points and gives him an abstract ideal to fight for. But with Alice, Hellboy has at least found an emotional anchor and one human connection.

Hellboy The Wild Hunt 2 pg 9

None of this should be misinterpreted to mean that The Wild Hunt doesn't  have its fair share of ass kicking. Mignola has given Hellboy more than the usual "just doing my job" rationale when its hero was working for the BPRD. But this story functions as an interlude before the long delayed showdown between Hellboy and the forces of Hell commited to destroying the world.

1/12/2010

Clickety-Click

Sorry for the lack of posts this year. I've been concentrating on trying to get my photoblog up and running, and I haven't kept up with my comics reading. Some new content should be appearing later this week; I hope.

update: alternate site

Philippine Camera Club, Rockwell, Makati
Philippine Camera Club, Rockwell, Makati
Philippine Camera Club members and pics from last night

1/02/2010

More NonSense: 2D and Plastic Girlfriends

DAR! A Super Girly Top Secret Comic Diary by Erika Moen. Erika Moen and the end of DAR! A Super Girly Top Secret Comic Diary

What if Galactus was like climate change?

Gravity Wells: Another schematic strip by xkcd.

Ben Caldwell art blog.

Government comics.

Comics

Timothy Hodler on Art Spiegelman's book In The Shadow Of No Towers. The latest in a series of The Comics Reporter Holiday Interviews. All are worth checking out.
It is fascinating to me how much "alternative" comic-book artists have avoided the politics and history of the Bush era. It's a far cry from the underground days. I don't know whether that's good or bad, but it's understandable, as it's hard to make political art that is actually art. But I remember when Zap #15 came out, which included a Gilbert Shelton Wonder Warthog story that took on contemporary American politics. It wasn't really a particularly good strip, actually, but it still felt like something of an indictment of the timidity of so many current younger cartoonists. Then again, the culture has changed, and as I said above, I don't believe that artists have a responsibility to take on these things unless they feel the calling. It still seems remarkable that so few do feel the calling.
Alan Moore the alpha geek.

Jason Thompson on the rise and fall of the meido craze.

Bill Randall on the rise of manga in the West.

Gerry Alanguilan looks back at 2009.

The Internet

Plastic and 2d girlfriends meme Even though I spent Christmas with my family, I could have also spent it with my 2D And Plastic Girlfriends like a good otaku.

Nate Silver claims the Internet is underrated.

Will the studios please increase their online distribution?

Animation

Dan Kois picks Spirited Away as one of their films of the decade. And another critic uses Hayao Miyazaki to beat up Pixar. Pathetic really.

Geek Toys

John Siracusa poors some cold reality and analyzes the Apple Tablet rumors.

World

Dana White declares the UFC will rule the world by 2020. MWA-HA-HA-HA-HA! Dream on Dana.